Availability for 1 new client for Q2 2026.
BTNG
Book a call
· 11 min read

Shopify UX Audit Europe: 7 Mistakes EU Stores Get Wrong

EU Shopify stores face GDPR, VAT display rules, iDEAL requirements, and checkout assumptions built for US markets. Here's what to audit first.

Ecommerce Shopify UX Audit
Shopify UX Audit Europe: 7 Mistakes EU Stores Get Wrong

Shopify was built for North American e-commerce. That’s not a complaint. It’s a fact that affects every EU store using it.

Most of the platform’s defaults — checkout flow, payment method prioritization, VAT display, GDPR consent handling — are built around US user behavior and US legal requirements. EU stores have to work around those defaults. Most don’t know which ones they’re still using.

This guide covers the 7 most common Shopify UX mistakes in EU stores, based on BTNG’s audit work across Dutch, Belgian, and German e-commerce brands. Each one has a real conversion cost and a specific fix.

Why Shopify Audits in Europe Are Different

EU-specific audit criteria that don’t apply to US stores:

Legal layer: GDPR cookie consent, VAT display rules (inclusive vs exclusive), EAA accessibility requirements (mandatory from June 2025)

Payment layer: iDEAL (Netherlands), Bancontact (Belgium), SEPA Direct Debit, local BNPL options (Klarna, Riverty) — Shopify’s default payment UI doesn’t prioritize these

Language layer: Multi-currency and multi-language complexity that Shopify Markets handles inconsistently

Expectation layer: EU consumers expect different return norms, shipping speeds, and trust signals than US consumers

A Shopify UX audit for an EU store has to check for all of these — not just standard CRO heuristics.

Mistake 1: Hiding iDEAL Behind “More Payment Options”

For Dutch stores, this is the single most expensive UX mistake on Shopify.

iDEAL accounts for roughly 60% of Dutch online payments. Betaalvereniging Nederland’s 2023 data puts it higher — closer to 65% for pure e-commerce transactions. When a Dutch customer reaches checkout and doesn’t immediately see iDEAL, a significant percentage of them do not complete the purchase. They don’t look for it. They don’t scroll. They leave.

Shopify’s default checkout payment UI shows cards first. iDEAL, if enabled, often appears under a “More options” or “Other payment methods” disclosure.

The audit check: On your Shopify checkout’s payment step, what is the first payment method shown? Is iDEAL immediately visible without any click or scroll?

The fix:

  • Use Shopify Payments with the Dutch payment methods enabled
  • Or use Mollie, MultiSafePay, or Adyen as your payment provider — all three allow you to control payment method ordering
  • Verify that iDEAL appears above credit cards in the payment list for Dutch visitors
  • Same principle applies for Bancontact (Belgium) and Giropay (Germany)

Mistake 2: Showing Prices Exclusive of VAT

Dutch, Belgian, and German consumers expect prices to include VAT. It’s legally required for B2C sales in most EU countries. And even where it isn’t legally required to display inclusive prices throughout the store, the expectation is set.

When a Dutch customer sees a product at €42 on your category page, then sees €50.82 at checkout (€42 + 21% VAT), they feel deceived. That gap at checkout is one of the primary drivers of abandonment — Baymard Institute identifies “unexpected costs at checkout” as the #1 reason, at 49% of abandonment events.

The audit check: Browse your store as a visitor. Navigate to a product page. Note the price. Now go through checkout. Does the price change between product page and the checkout summary? By how much? Is VAT displayed separately or rolled in?

The fix:

  • In Shopify Markets settings, enable “Include taxes in prices” for EU regions
  • Audit your product page pricing, cart, and checkout summary for consistency
  • If you sell B2B and need to show prices ex-VAT, use a separate B2B storefront or dedicated B2B pricing display (not a single store that shows different prices by login state without explanation)

GDPR requires consent for non-essential cookies. Most Shopify stores implement this with a third-party cookie banner. Most of those banners are implemented wrong — either technically, legally, or from a conversion standpoint.

The conversion problem: banners that take over the screen, can’t be easily dismissed, or require clicking through three pages to decline all cookies add friction before the customer even sees a product. Baymard found that modal overlays at page load increase bounce rates significantly on mobile.

Common EU cookie consent mistakes on Shopify:

  • Banner fires on every page, not just on first visit
  • “Accept all” button is large and prominent; “Decline” or “Manage” is hidden or very small
  • Banner uses dark patterns (declining is technically possible but requires 5 clicks)
  • The banner is loaded from a slow third-party CDN and delays page rendering
  • Analytics stop working completely when cookies are declined (fix: use server-side analytics or anonymous tracking)

The audit check:

  1. Open your store in an incognito window on mobile
  2. Note what percentage of the viewport the cookie banner covers
  3. Count how many taps it takes to decline all non-essential cookies
  4. Check if the page loads normally after declining

The fix:

  • Use a lightweight, GDPR-compliant cookie consent tool (Cookiebot, CookieYes, or Pandectes for Shopify)
  • Ensure “Accept” and “Decline” are equally prominent (Dutch DPA guidance specifically addresses dark patterns)
  • Implement consent-mode compatible analytics (Google Consent Mode v2) so you don’t lose all data when users decline
  • For Shopify specifically: Shopify’s native cookie banner is now available and is the most lightweight option for basic compliance

Mistake 4: Checkout Doesn’t Handle EU Addresses Correctly

Shopify’s address form defaults are built for US addresses. European addresses work differently — and the form fields often fight against EU users.

Specific problems:

Dutch postal codes. Dutch postcodes are 4 digits + 2 letters (e.g., 1234 AB). Shopify’s default postcode field accepts this, but it doesn’t auto-format or validate the pattern. Users frequently type “1234AB” (no space) and get a validation error on downstream delivery services.

House number extensions. Dutch and Belgian addresses often have house number additions: “12a”, “12-I”, “12 Boven”. Shopify’s single “Address Line 2” field handles this poorly — many users don’t know whether to put the addition on line 1 or line 2.

German address format. German addresses put street name before house number (“Musterstraße 12”, not “12 Musterstraße”). Shopify’s form doesn’t prompt for this order, and some integrations parse the address incorrectly.

The audit check: Go through checkout with a Dutch address (e.g., Keizersgracht 177, 1016 DR Amsterdam). Does the form accept it cleanly? Does it pre-fill correctly from browser autofill? Does the delivery confirmation show the address correctly formatted?

The fix:

  • Use an address validation app (Postcode.nl API integration for Dutch stores, Address Validator for EU-wide)
  • Add a dedicated “House number” or “Addition” field if your carrier integration requires it
  • Test autofill behavior on Chrome, Safari iOS, and Firefox for EU address formats
  • Coordinate with your fulfillment partner — some Dutch fulfillment centers require specific address field formats

Mistake 5: Mobile Checkout Not Optimized for EU Payment Methods

Mobile conversion in the EU averages 1.2–1.8% lower than desktop. That gap is larger for stores with native payment methods (iDEAL, Bancontact) because the redirect flows these methods use are poorly handled on mobile.

iDEAL on mobile routes users to their banking app, then back to the store. If the return redirect fails — a known issue with some Shopify payment integrations — the customer lands on a blank page or error screen. The order went through but the customer thinks it failed. They contact support, get confused, or abandon entirely.

The audit check:

  1. Complete a test purchase on mobile using iDEAL
  2. Time how long the banking app handoff takes
  3. Verify the redirect back to your order confirmation page works correctly
  4. Check that the order confirmation email fires immediately after the iDEAL confirmation (not only after manual bank confirmation)

The fix:

  • Use a payment provider that handles iDEAL mobile redirects reliably (Mollie and Adyen both have strong track records here)
  • Test the full mobile payment flow on actual devices — not just browser emulation
  • Implement Shopify’s Shop Pay Installments as an additional option for mobile users who want to avoid banking app redirects
  • Add a “Your order is confirmed” animation or page that fires immediately after redirect, before the confirmation email arrives

Mistake 6: Multi-Language Implementation That Hurts SEO

Many EU Shopify stores operate in multiple languages. The standard implementation is to use Shopify’s native translation features or a third-party app (Langify, Weglot, Transcy). Most of these are implemented in ways that either hurt SEO or create a broken UX.

Common problems:

  • Translated pages don’t have hreflang tags implemented correctly, so Google serves the wrong language to the wrong country
  • URL structure is inconsistent: /nl/product-name vs /product-name?lang=nl vs a subdomain — Shopify handles these differently and not all apps implement them correctly
  • Translated copy is machine-translated and clearly wrong (product descriptions, error messages, checkout copy)
  • The language switcher is hidden or confusing — users on the wrong language version don’t know how to switch
  • Cart and checkout revert to English even when the rest of the store is in Dutch

The audit check:

  • Open your Dutch-language store in an English-language browser and check if hreflang is correctly telling Google this page is for Dutch speakers
  • Go through the full checkout flow in Dutch — does it stay in Dutch through payment confirmation?
  • Check 10 product descriptions for obvious machine translation errors

The fix:

  • Implement hreflang correctly using the ISO 639-1 language code + ISO 3166-1 country code: nl-NL for Dutch Netherlands, nl-BE for Dutch Belgium
  • Use Shopify Markets with dedicated storefronts per region where possible
  • Have native speakers review key pages: homepage, product pages, checkout error messages, confirmation emails
  • Language switcher should be in the header navigation, always visible, and persist through checkout

Mistake 7: Shopify’s Checkout Customization Limits Create EU-Specific Problems

Shopify Basic and Shopify (non-Plus) have significant checkout customization restrictions. You can’t add custom fields, change the checkout template, or reorder payment methods. This creates problems specifically for EU stores:

  • You can’t add a checkbox for “I agree with the terms and conditions” required by some EU member states
  • You can’t add a field for “VAT number” for B2B buyers in EU (needed for reverse charge VAT)
  • You can’t add a delivery date picker required for some fresh food or perishable product categories
  • You can’t display local certification logos (Thuiswinkel Waarborg) within the checkout frame

The audit check: List every piece of information you legally or operationally need to collect at checkout. Compare that list against what Shopify’s default checkout collects. Document the gaps.

The fix:

  • Evaluate Shopify Plus if checkout customization is critical (Plus allows Checkout Extensibility)
  • For B2B VAT number collection: use Shopify’s draft orders flow or a B2B app that collects VAT ID before or after checkout
  • For terms agreement: some EU DPAs accept a clear statement near the “Place Order” button instead of a checkbox — verify what your local DPA requires
  • Document the gaps in your checkout and make a cost/benefit case for whether Shopify Plus upgrade is justified by revenue impact

How to Run Your Own Shopify EU Audit

Use this sequence:

Day 1 — Payment and pricing

  • Test checkout with each payment method you accept
  • Verify iDEAL (or Bancontact, Giropay) is immediately visible
  • Verify prices are VAT-inclusive throughout the funnel

Day 2 — Mobile and redirect flows

  • Complete a full purchase on mobile for each payment method
  • Verify redirect back from banking app works
  • Time the mobile checkout flow (should be under 3 minutes for a returning customer)

Day 3 — Legal and compliance

  • Test cookie consent banner on mobile incognito
  • Count clicks to decline all cookies
  • Check hreflang implementation with Google Search Console or a hreflang checker

Day 4 — Address and form UX

  • Test checkout with Dutch, German, and Belgian address formats
  • Check autofill behavior on Chrome and Safari
  • Verify confirmation email arrives within 60 seconds of order placement

Day 5 — Review and prioritize

  • List every issue found, with a screenshot
  • Rate severity: Critical (blocks purchase), Major (adds significant friction), Minor (small UX improvement)
  • Fix Critical issues this week. Major issues this sprint. Minor issues when you have bandwidth.

Get Your Free Shopify UX Scorecard

Going through this audit manually takes 3–5 days. BTNG offers a free 30-minute Shopify UX review call for EU stores — we look at your store together, identify your 3–5 highest-priority issues, and give you a prioritized fix list.

No pitch. No deck. Just a look at your actual Shopify store.

Book your free Shopify UX review →

Back to articles

Get articles in your inbox

Weekly e-commerce UX tips. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Subscribe